NOTE : Product prices, availability, ratings and save money information are accurate as of the date/time indicated on post time (as seen right bellow the tittle) and are subject to change. Any price, ratings, availability and save money information displayed on Amazon Site at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Choosing the right infant formula can be utterly confusing, but there are several notable products on the market that are very popular amongst parents due to their effectiveness in providing both comfort and nutrition for the baby. Similac is one renowned brand that you can trust. It has been around since the late 1920s, and is marketed by Abbott Laboratories. The brand is now known to produce a variety of milk formulas for specific needs and conditions. Below, we are going to see the comparisons between two Similac products, Similac Total Comfort vs Similac Spit Up.
Both Similac Total Comfort and Similac Spit Up are gentle infant milk formulas that can help babies with fussiness, gas, and spit-up problems. So, what is actually the difference between these two formulas? We will break down the comparisons into several aspects to allow better understanding of these two infant milk formulas.
Packaging and Sizes
First of all, the easiest way to tell Similac Total Comfort vs Similac Spit Up apart is by the color theme of the packaging. The Total Comfort is sold in purple packaging, whereas the Spit Up is sold in green packaging – the one with the golden packaging is here: Similac Total Comfort vs Similac Pro Sensitive. Of course, they clearly state their names on each packaging, so there is no way to mistake the products.
Similac Total Comfort is available as powder in tubes and cans. The tube packaging is available in the 1.41 lbs (22.5 oz) size. Meanwhile, the can packaging is usually sold in the 12 oz size. This milk formula doesn’t have any ready-to-feed product.
On the other hand, Similac Spit Up is unique because it is available as both powder and ready-to-feed products. Just like the Total Comfort, it is available in tubes (1.41 lbs / 22.5 oz) and cans (12 oz). In addition, the Spit Up ready-to-feed bottle has the 32 fl oz size. This version is very convenient and practical to use. When you are very busy and your child wants to feed, you won’t have to spoil milk powder all over your kitchen – simply take the ready-to-feed bottle.
Special Considerations
Both Similac Total Comfort and Similac Spit Up proudly display their non-GMO labels on their packaging. Why is being non-GMO important, especially for an infant milk formula? That is because genetic modification on ingredients, while beneficial in some ways, is worried to cause a side-effect of producing new allergens. There hasn’t been enough study to prove whether genetic modification can really create new allergens or not. But, just to be safe, you want to avoid giving genetically modified ingredients to your child. Both Similac Total Comfort and Similac Spit Up are non-GMO products; they don’t use any genetically modified ingredients.
Both Similac Total Comfort and Similar Spit Up are also certified to be gluten-free, halal, and kosher. They don’t contain any gluten, so they are safe choices for children with a gluten allergy.
However, when choosing between Similac Total Comfort vs Similac Spit Up, keep in mind that they both contain lactose and soy. Be careful if your child is allergic to lactose or soy; if your child isn’t allergic to either, there is no reason to avoid these substances. They both are also not suitable for children with galactosemia, which is a very rare genetic disorder that reduces the sufferer’s ability to metabolize the galactose sugar.
The Proteins
Although these two milk formulas look very similar, they actually come with very different ingredients. The first six ingredients of Similac Total Comfort are maltodextrin, whey protein hydrolysate, safflower oil, sugar, soy oil, and coconut oil. On the other hand, the first six ingredients of Similac Spit Up include corn syrup, modified rice starch, milk protein isolate, safflower oil, sugar, soy oil (and coconut oil).
The first important difference between these two products is the protein break-down level. Similac Total Comfort is armed with partially broken down proteins. One of the possible causes of a baby’s fussiness and gas problems is stomach discomfort, which can be caused by the baby’s inability to digest complex milk proteins. Similac Total Comfort contains proteins molecules that have been broken into smaller, simpler pieces in order to make them easier to digest.
In fact, Similac Total Comfort has been very simplified that it only uses whey protein hydrolysate. A whole protein consists of whey and casein, but Similac Total Comfort only uses the whey part and not the casein part to make it suitable for children with lactose intolerance.
On the other hand, Similac Spit Up actually uses regular milk proteins, but that does not mean that the formula isn’t gentle. In fact, Similac Spit Up is a gentle milk formula by a different way. It contains rice starch, which thickens the texture of the formula. It says that the rice starch makes the formula gentler and easier to digest.
Maltodextrin or Corn Syrup
The second difference between Similac Total Comfort vs Similac Spit Up in terms of the ingredients is the maltodextrin and corn syrup. The Total Comfort contains maltodextrin, whereas the Spit Up uses corn syrup. Which one is better? If you browse the Internet, you can see that both maltodextrin and corn syrup may have bad effects if consumed excessively, but they are safe in moderate amounts. You can be certain that the manufacturer has carefully developed these products with the right amounts to make them safe for your baby’s consumption.
Effectiveness
Both products have received many positive reviews, so you can tell that they both work. However, they are effective in different cases. If your child is not allergic to lactose, but he or she experiences feeding problems, you can choose Similac Spit Up. In this case, you don’t need to give your child partially broken down proteins. The rice starch really helps to make it gentle to the child’s stomach.
However, if your child can’t digest lactose, you should choose Similac Total Comfort. The simplified proteins will make it work great.
| Similac Total Comfort | Similac Spit Up | |
|---|---|---|
| Key features | - Similac Total Comfort Infant Formula provides complete nutrition for your baby's first year and is formulated to be gentle on tiny tummies with partially broken down protein for easy digestion, prebiotics for softer stools - NUTRIENTS: Features OptiGRO, our exclusive blend of DHA, Lutein and Vitamin E, special nutrients found in breast milk that are important for helping support baby's brain and eye development | - Similac for Spit-Up Infant Formula is a nutritionally complete formula specially formulated with rice starch and clinically shown to reduce spit-up in healthy infants by 54%* - *Reduced frequency among 2 month old healthy infants compared to a standard milk-based formula (Lasekan JB et al. J Am Coll Nutr. 2014;33(2):136-146) |
| Price | ||
| Customer ratings* | 4.3 out of 5.0 stars | 4.2 out of 5.0 stars |
| Best deal* | Save Money Please click here | Save Money Please click here |
NOTE : Product prices, availability, ratings and save money information are accurate as of the date/time indicated on post time (as seen right bellow the tittle) and are subject to change. Any price, ratings, availability and save money information displayed on Amazon Site at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Conclusion
Similac Total Comfort and Similac Spit Up are made for different needs. If you are not sure about what causes your child’s feeding problem, you can start with Similac Spit Up. It is a gentle formula that uses rice starch. It has been proven to work on many babies. However, if your child has been diagnosed with lactose intolerance, or if Similac Spit Up doesn’t work, you should choose Similac Total Comfort, which has simplified proteins.