NOTE : Product prices, availability, ratings and save money information are accurate as of the date/time indicated on post time (as seen right bellow the tittle) and are subject to change. Any price, ratings, availability and save money information displayed on Amazon Site at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
As a parent, you certainly want to give your baby all the best foods and nutrients that he or she needs. That is why choosing the right milk formula for your baby is incredibly important. Any person who have experienced the conditions and problems faced by a first-time parent will tell you that choosing the right baby formula is never easy. We definitely don’t want to experiment, but sometimes we can’t help but to try what other fellow parents recommend. It can help, sometimes, but different babies sometimes have different needs.
If your baby’s stomach is sensitive and he or she gets problems from other milk formulas, you probably need to consider a special milk formula that has been designed for sensitive tummies. Such special milk formulas typically have partially or completely broken down proteins and avoid using certain ingredients that may cause allergic reactions. Two milk formulas that are popular for such case are Similac Total Comfort and Gerber Soothe. Both are said to be safe for sensitive tummies, but do they really work? See the comparisons below.
About Similac Total Comfort
Similac Total Comfort is a milk formula with partially broken down proteins to allow easy digestion. It says that it may help if your baby is having discomfort related to persistent feeding issues. It also claims to be a non-GMO product. However, it says that it is not suitable for infants and children with galactosemia.
It provides complete nutrition for the first year of your baby, but is formulated to be gentle on tiny tummies by using partially broken down proteins. It is also enhanced with prebiotics that can help the health of the baby’s digestion system and let out softer tools. It claims to be the number one infant formula chosen by moms and hospitals.
About Gerber Soothe
On the other hand, Gerber Soothe is designed specially for babies with excessive crying, colic, gas, and fussiness. It is made with small, easy to digest comfort proteins and comforting prebiotics. It contains the exclusive probiotic Lactobacillus reuteri, which is useful to comfort the digestion system of the baby and has been clinically shown to reduce crying time on colicky breastfed babies by 50%. The so-called “comfort proteins” are made composed of small partially broken proteins and 30% lactose to help in easing fussiness and gas. (Read also : Similac Alimentum Vs Gerber Soothe)
Similac Total Comfort vs. Gerber Soothe: Ingredients
First of all, Similac Total Comfort and Gerber Soother are similar in a way that they don’t contain any GMO ingredient. Why is that important? The term GMO stands for “genetically modified organism”. A genetically modified organism has its DNA altered or spliced in order to achieve a certain positive trait, such as resistance to disease and enhanced growth. However, a genetically modified organism may contain unknown allergens due to the alterations, and the use is often criticized because there is still little known about the possible side effects. Thus, many parents prefer to use non-GMO products especially for their babies who still have relatively weak digestion. When a baby develops feeding issues, there is a possibility that a GMO ingredient is the causing factor, and hence you may want to consider switching to Similac Total Comfort or Gerber Soothe.
Well, even though both Similac Total Comfort and Gerber Soothe are said to use “partially broken down proteins”, they are actually not very similar to each other. In general, Gerber Soothe can work because its proteins have indeed been simplified for easier digestion, but it still contains some lactose. This is not a problem at all, unless your baby is allergic to cow’s milk and lactose. There are many cases of babies developing colic and excessive crying issues because of lactose allergy. If your baby is not allergic to lactose, Gerber Soothe will possibly work. Otherwise, stay away from the milk formula.
Meanwhile, if your baby has used Gerber Soothe and is still colicky, there is a possibility that he or she is allergic to lactose. If that is the case, you probably have a better chance with Similac Total Comfort because it contains greatly reduced lactose. Compared to regular milk formulas, Similac Total Comfort contains 98% less lactose. So, it is less likely to cause an allergic reaction and may help your baby.
Both products are enhanced with probiotics, which can be beneficial to maintain and improve the health of the digestion system. However, Similac Total Comfort does not tell specifically what types of prebiotics that the formula contains. Gerber Soothe confidently shows that it contains Lactobacillus reuteri that has been clinically shown to help reduce colic and fussiness.
Similac Total Comfort vs. Gerber Soothe: Possible Side Effects
It is true that both Similac Total Comfort and Gerber Soothe have received lots of positive reviews praising their effectiveness. However, once again, different babies may develop reactions towards a formula. Therefore, we may need to know a little about what side effects that a formula may induce.
One important thing about Similac Total Comfort is that it has to be used within a month since it is opened. Once it is opened, it will start to degrade due to the exposure to air, and is only good for a month. Thus, it is great to be a primary formula, but not as a backup.
If they don’t work, Similac Total Comfort and Gerber Soothe may cause constipation and increased gas. Another possible side effect is that they may cause massive stinky blowouts.
| Similac Total Comfort | Gerber Soothe | |
|---|---|---|
| Key features | - Similac Total Comfort Infant Formula provides complete nutrition for your baby's first year and is formulated to be gentle on tiny tummies with partially broken down protein for easy digestion, prebiotics for softer stools | - 22.2 Ounce container, Pack of 6 - Makes 240, 4 Fluid Ounce bottles - Stage 1, birth-12 months: Exclusive probiotic L. reuteri, has been clinically shown to reduce crying time by 50% in colicky breastfed infants |
| Price | ||
| Customer ratings* | 4.3 out of 5.0 stars | 4.5 out of 5.0 stars |
| Best deal* | Save Money Please click here | Save Money Please click here |
NOTE : Product prices, availability, ratings and save money information are accurate as of the date/time indicated on post time (as seen right bellow the tittle) and are subject to change. Any price, ratings, availability and save money information displayed on Amazon Site at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Conclusion
You can use Gerber Soothe if your baby does not have any allergy to cow’s milk or lactose. This is because the milk formula still has a good amount of lactose that accompanies the partially broken down proteins. In addition, Gerber Soothe has also been enhanced with a great prebiotic, Lactobacillus reuteri, which can help the health of the digestion system. However, if your baby is allergic to cow’s milk or lactose, you should choose Similac Total Comfort instead. The lactose content has been greatly reduced, making it safe for even babies who are allergic to lactose.